F2 Anonboard :: Great books that were made into really shitty films

Back to Index | Reply to Topic

Page: 1 2 3 | Previous Next | First Last

Great books that were made into really shitty films

.
Unregistered

Posted 5/27/2012 4:38 am

. said:Atlas Shrugged

Go back to Soviet Russia libfag.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

BobHopesColostomyBag
Ripe Cerignola Olives

16429 posts

Posted 5/27/2012 4:38 am

. said:
BobHopesColostomyBag said:Lawrence of Arabia is a great movie...but it's nothing at all like Seven Pillars Of Wisdom.

When you've read Seven Pillars Of Wisdom you'll look at the movie and see that it's just....stupid.

Don't ever call a David Lean film stupid again.

Read it; you'll see that I'm right. And I love David Lean's Oliver Twist. Having said that I'm glad he never got to even start filming on Joseph Conrad's Nostromo.

http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5256/5420038262_ee0f9be065_z.jpg

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

calamari_wagon
Unregistered

Posted 5/27/2012 4:38 am

magbas_2012 said:
calamari_wagon said:Last Exit To Brooklyn - Hubert Selby Jr.
Tin Drum - Gunter Grass
Midnight Express
Naked Lunch (but I didn't expect much from a Cronenberg film anyway)

The Doors wasn't a book but pretty much the entire film was boring and completely inaccurate.

I thought Midnight Express was a good movie, but I never read the book.

If you've never read the book, it's a fantastic movie. With a great score too.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

.
Unregistered

Posted 5/27/2012 4:38 am

Dune

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

.
Unregistered

Posted 5/27/2012 4:39 am

magbas_2012 said:
calamari_wagon said:Last Exit To Brooklyn - Hubert Selby Jr.
Tin Drum - Gunter Grass
Midnight Express
Naked Lunch (but I didn't expect much from a Cronenberg film anyway)

The Doors wasn't a book but pretty much the entire film was boring and completely inaccurate.

I thought Midnight Express was a good movie, but I never read the book.

The book was amazing. I picked it up as some hotel in France when I was in college, there was some shelf in the lobby where Americans and English would trade books. Another book I picked up there was Not Without My Daughter, which was a great book that was far better than the movie.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

.
Unregistered

Posted 5/27/2012 4:41 am

BobHopesColostomyBag said:Read it; you'll see that I'm right. And I love David Lean's Oliver Twist. Having said that I'm glad he never got to even start filming on Joseph Conrad's Nostromo.

http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5256/5420038262_ee0f9be065_z.jpg

Even if you are right, I'll still love the film as a work of art in its own right.

Oliver Twist was superb, but Great Expectations was even better.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

.
Unregistered

Posted 5/27/2012 4:44 am

Curious George

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

BobHopesColostomyBag
Ripe Cerignola Olives

16429 posts

Posted 5/27/2012 4:45 am

. said:
BobHopesColostomyBag said:Read it; you'll see that I'm right. And I love David Lean's Oliver Twist. Having said that I'm glad he never got to even start filming on Joseph Conrad's Nostromo.

http://farm6.staticflickr.com/5256/5420038262_ee0f9be065_z.jpg

Even if you are right, I'll still love the film as a work of art in its own right.

Oliver Twist was superb, but Great Expectations was even better.

No it wasn't and I'll tell you why: Oliver Twist totally captures the essence of the book and it's original illustrations. It's a perfect movie, like Tony Richardson's Tom Jones.

But Great Expectations is compromised particularly in its ending, and the compromises in the plot destroy the entire moral purpose of the story.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

.
Unregistered

Posted 5/27/2012 4:53 am

BobHopesColostomyBag said:No it wasn't and I'll tell you why: Oliver Twist totally captures the essence of the book and it's original illustrations. It's a perfect movie, like Tony Richardson's Tom Jones.

But Great Expectations is compromised particularly in its ending, and the compromises in the plot destroy the entire moral purpose of the story.

Thanks for the lesson, wise one.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

dotmatrix
Hyper Kitten

3858 posts

Posted 5/27/2012 4:58 am

The Color of Money was nothing like the book. The Hustler was great, though. Walter Tevis is one of my favorite authors.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

magbas_2012
Just fuck off

3421 posts

Posted 5/27/2012 5:00 am

BobHopesColostomyBag said:No it wasn't and I'll tell you why: Oliver Twist totally captures the essence of the book and it's original illustrations. It's a perfect movie, like Tony Richardson's Tom Jones.

But Great Expectations is compromised particularly in its ending, and the compromises in the plot destroy the entire moral purpose of the story.

The 69 musical version Oliver! was pretty damn good. I should know.

Quote Single Quote Nested Link

Page: 1 2 3 | Previous Next | First Last

Back to Index | Reply to Topic

	Navigation \| Options \| Login \| Register \| Status \| FAQ \| Upload Pics \| Work-Safe